Sign Up for Insider Info!

Book Review: In Her Shadow, by August McLaughlin

In Her Shadow, by August McLaughlinI don’t read psychological thrillers very often. It’s not that I don’t like them, I do. It’s that they tend to keep me up at night and turn me into a shivering pile of goo. I have a very active imagination, and it comes alive when I read. As in, really alive. So alive that I see things streak across the room and hide under the bed, the better to grab me later when I’m trying to sleep. So when I pick up a psychological thriller I have to be ready for about a week of paranoia.

In Her Shadow is the debut novel by August McLaughlin. Did it keep me up at night? Yes! Did it creep me out with thoughts of what people will do to one another? Hell yes. It took me to dark, scary places and turned out the light, then twisted a knife in my back.

I liked it, in other words. It did everything a thriller should do, particularly this kind. There’s underlying subtext of eating disorders and child sexual abuse that are dark, horrifying, and aren’t even worst part of the story. It travels a deep, dark, winding road into crazy.

First Line: “She gulps the swig of poison like an eight year old inhaling cough syrup—nose plugged, eyes squeezed shut, her face pulled into a tight round ball. Toxic, metallic tasting vapors trail the liquid down her throat, filling her with venomous stench and nausea. Swallow, she instructs. Gulp. Breathe. There, that’s it. She did it. 

She trembles on the floor, her sweaty back pressed against the bedside, awaiting action. The wrapper from the candy bar he forced into her mouth lies on the floor beside her, crumpled like an odd bit of wrapping paper on Christmas morning. No celebrations today, though. Well, maybe after.”

These first lines hooked me for so many reasons. Why is this girl killing herself? Why had someone forced her to eat a candy bar? What the heck is going on? Enough to keep reading, and enough to set the tone for the whole story. Horrifying. I’m there with this girl immediately.

Another thing I loved about this story was the hint of something paranormal or supernatural or psychic going on. No, it’s not a fantasy book. But it has just enough weirdness to grab my attention and not let go.

One word about the structure. I’ve mentioned it before, several times, that I’m not a fan of present tense. This novel is entirely in present tense. It really did bother me all the way through the story, but…I almost thank the author for it. Why? Because I was so freaked out by the story that the present tense pulled me away enough to enable me to finish reading it. I know, I’m very strange. Here’s the thing…to me, present tense is meant for screenwriting. It’s distancing. It puts the reader at the point of view of a camera looking at a scene, rather than allowing the reader to become part of the scene. That generally drives me crazy, because I want to crawl inside my stories and live there. I can’t do that if I’m way out in left field with the camera.

The only time present tense works for me is if the story is dialogue heavy. It’s just not as noticeable if it’s full of talking bits, which makes perfect sense since, after all, it’s meant for plays and movies (mostly talk).

This story is not dialogue heavy, and it’s not an action thriller. This is a psychological thriller, so the mind plays a huge part and dialogue doesn’t. I was constantly tripped up by the “s” at the end of words. Yes, it bothers me that much.

That said, I wouldn’t discount the story for my personal preference and like I said, in this case it let some of the tension off the hook for me and let me enjoy the story instead of clutching my Kindle as melted into a quivering tiny ball in the corner. Besides, I could see this as a movie and in that case, half the script is already done.

If you like dark psychological thrillers, give this one a try.

What do you think about present tense in novels? Does it bother you?

8 comments on… “Book Review: In Her Shadow, by August McLaughlin”

  1. I really dislike present tense in books, but I especially loathe it in first person. I used to not even pick up books written in present tense until I tried a couple by IRL writing friends last year, and they were so good I didn’t notice for several chapters! This sounds lik it might very well be another of those, so it’s on my TBR pile for sure!

    • I’m with you, if it’s first person present I won’t even read it. I just can’t get past that. third person present, as this is, I can overlook if a number of other things are present. Great writing, griping story, a lot of dialogue…some combination of those things will get me to look past the present tense. The Night Circus was another one I loved despite the present tense. Still say it would have played better in third person…but that’s just me 😉

  2. Thanks for reading my novel, Melinda, and for the lovely review!

    I’m surprised that you’re the first person to chime in (at least openly :)) about its tense. Present tense and dark psychological plots definitely aren’t everyone’s cup of reading tea… That you looked beyond those factors to read my story in full and find strengths means so much. Cheers!

    • Thanks for stopping by August! 🙂 I’m glad you didn’t get hung up on my tense quibbles! It’s a griping story, well worth the read. I usually save my dark psychological thrillers for the big screen because they end faster heh. Your story was more than enough to keep me hooked until the very end. I simply HAD to find out how it ended or I wouldn’t have been able to sleep. Hallmark of a good story right there, whatever the tense 🙂

  3. Great review Melinda! I understand your feelings on present tense. Yet, it seems that our August has just been nominated for an award for her first thriller novel. That surely an honor indeed. Now, what I am waiting for is the story about you and your hubby. I’ve seen the wedding pics Melinda. Please do share your story with us. Hell may freeze over, but for some reason I know there is a beautiful story there. 🙂

    • That sounds like a good post for May…our anniversary 🙂 Hopefully Hell won’t freeze over before then. Er, or maybe it should? I’m confused LOL

  4. Yay, I finally got my internet back and got to read your review, Melinda. What a great review! You really have a knack for writing them. I’m such a big scaredy cat, too, and this book scared the heck out of me. I was literally shaking reading it and even after I finished. It’s an excellent psychological thriller. Present tense doesn’t bother me at all. There are so many YA books that are written in present tense these days that I’m used to it. So I didn’t have that to pull me out of the story and make it not as intense. Nope, I was seriously freaked out reading this book. Like you, I had to read the whole story to find out what happened!

  5. Great review, Melinda. I need to bump this up my TBR. I think I need to keep it to day reading, though. 😉 Like Lynn, present tense doesn’t bother me. It’s very prevalent in YA, which is the forum I am fond to with my own writing, as you know.

It gets lonely out here in the big wide webs. Talk to me!